Skip to main content

Table 2 Basic functional performance

From: Can in-hospital or post discharge caregiver involvement increase functional performance of older patients? A systematic review

Study Measure points

 

Basic ADL

Extended ADL

Others

Everink et al 2018

 

KI, mean (SD)

 

FAI, mean (SD)

T0= admission geriatric rehabilitation

 

T1

T2

 

T1

T2

T1= 3 months

IG

4.6 (2.4)

4.4 (2.9)

31.1 (9.4)

31.0 (9.4)

T2= 9 months

CG

5.7 (2.8)

5.0 (3.0)

27.4 (9.7)

29.4 (11.2)

  

p = 0.360

p = 0.862

p = 0.014

p = 0.288

Forster et al 2013

  

NEADL, mean (SE)

 

T0= baseline

  

T1

 

T1= 6 months

IG

27.4 (1.00)

T2= 12 months

CG

27.6 (0.99)

  

p = 0.866

Galvin et al 2011

 

BI, mean change (SD)

NEADL, mean change (SD)

RNLI, mean change (SD)

T0= baseline

 

T1 - T0

T2 - T1

T2 – T1

T2 – T1

T1= 8 weeks

IG

32.3 (24)

3.8 (8.3)

7.6 (8.3)

4.7 (4.3)

T2= 3 months

CG

16.3 (14.2)

1.5 (11.6)

3.6 (7.8)

0.4 (2.9)

  

p = 0.04

p = 0.36

p = 0.02

p = 0.00

Gräsel et al 2005

 

BI, mean change (SD)

  
  

T2 – T0

  

T0= after intervention

IG

11.4 (14.1)

T2= 6 months

CG

11.2 (16.4)

  

p = 0.968

  

FIM, mean change (SD)

  
  

T2 – T0

  

IG

2.5 (12.9)

CG

7.4 (12.2)

 

p = 0.129

Hebel et al 2014

 

BI, median

NEADL, median

MRS, median

T0= after intervention

 

T0

T1

T2

T1

T2

 

T0

T1

T2

T1= 3 months

IG

60

75

90

7

14

 

3

2

2

T2= 12 months

CG

72.5

85

90

13

14.5

 

2

2

2

  

p = 0.02

p = 0.07

p = 0.65

p = 0.004

p = 0.27

 

p = 0.11

p = 0.18

p = 0.53

Kalra/Patel et al 2004

 

BI, BI >18

 

FAI, median (IQR)

T0= baseline

 

T2

T4

 

T0

T4

T2= 12 weeks

IG

51.3%

61.5%

25 (20 - 29)

15 (9 - 23)

T4= 52 weeks

CG

34.8%

50.3%

24 (21 - 29)

16 (8 - 22)

  

p = 0.007

p = 0.074

p = not stated

p= not stated

van den Berg et al 2016

 

BI, mean (95% CI)

NEADL, mean (95% CI)

  

T0= baseline

 

T1

T2

T1

T2

 

T1= 8 weeks

IG

89.3 (81.6 - 97)

89.4 (81.7 - 97.1)

14.3 (12.1-16.4)

15.9 (13.8-18.1)

T2= 12 weeks

CG

84.9 (78.7 - 91)

88.7 (82.4 - 94.9)

10.7 (9 - 12.4)

12.9 (11.1-14.6)

  

p = 0.3811

p = 0.8894

p = 0.0118

p= 0.0319

  1. IG Intervention Group, CG Control Group, KI Katz Index, BI Barthel Index, FIM Functional Independence Measure, NEADL Nottingham Extended Activities of Daily Living, FAI Frenchay Activity Index, RNLI Reintegration to Normal Living Index, MRS Modified Rankin Scale