A critical review of the long-term disability outcomes following hip fracture

Dyer, Suzanne M.; Crotty, Maria; Fairhall, Nicola; Magaziner, Jay; Beaupre, Lauren A.; Cameron, Ian D.; Sherrington, Catherine

doi:10.1186/s12877-016-0332-0

BMC Geriatrics

Table 1 Summary of included cohort studies, with outcomes included in review categorised using ICF framework^a

From: A critical review of the long-term disability outcomes following hip fracture

Author, year	Country	N (hip fracture)	Recruitment	Activity			Participation			Health condition	Accomm	QOL	Mortality
Author, year	Country	N (hip fracture)	Recruitment	Mobility	Basic ADL	Self care	IADLs	Domestic	Community	Health condition	Accomm	QOL	Mortality
Relative to non-fracture group
Autier 2000 [18]^b	Belgium	170	1995–1996								Yes		Yes
Boonen 2004 [19]^b	Belgium	170	1995–1996	Yes	Yes					Yes		Yes	Yes
Cumming 1996 [20]	Australia	131	1990–1992								Yes		Yes
Magaziner 2003^c [21]	USA	594	1990–1991	Yes		Yes
Marottoli 1992^{d, e} [16]	USA	120	1982–1988	Yes		Yes							Yes
Norton 2000 [22]	New Zealand	911	1991–1994	Yes	Yes
Tosteson 2001 [23]	USA	67	NR	Yes	Yes
Wolinsky 1997^e [17]	USA	368	1984–1991	Yes	Yes		Yes	Yes					Yes
Population-based cohorts
Bentler 2009 [14]	USA	495	1993–2005	Yes	Yes		Yes			Yes			Yes
Marottoli 1994^d [15]	USA	120	1982–1988								Yes		Yes
No comparison group
Abimanyi-Ochom 2015 [30]	Australia	224	2009–2012									Yes
Beaupre 2005 [50]^f	Canada	919	1999–2000 & 1996–1997		Yes						Yes		Yes
Beaupre 2007 [48]^f	Canada	451	1999–2000	Yes	Yes	Yes							Yes
Borgquist 1990 [31]	Sweden	103	1976–1977	Yes		Yes		Yes	Yes		Yes		Yes
Borgquist 1991 [32]	Sweden	837	1986–1988	Yes	Yes	Yes		Yes	Yes		Yes		Yes
Borgström 2013 [33]	International	1273	2003, 2007–2010									Yes
Crotty 2000 [49]	Australia	215	1998–1999	Yes	Yes						Yes		Yes
Doshi 2014 [61]	Singapore	219	2011–NR		Yes								Yes
Givens 2008 [52]	USA	126	NR	Yes	Yes						Yes		Yes
Griffin 2015 [46]	UK	741	2012–2014	Yes								Yes	Yes
Holt 2008 [62]	Scotland	16380	1998–2005	Yes								Yes	Yes
Keene 1993 [41]	UK	1000	1989–1992	Yes				Yes				Yes	Yes
Kitamura 1998 [34]^g	Japan	1169	1992	Yes	Yes	Yes					Yes		Yes
Tsuboi 2007 [35]^g	Japan	963	1992	Yes							Yes		Yes
Koval 1998 [44]	USA	631	1987–1995	Yes									Yes
Koval 1998 [51]	USA	398	1988–1990		Yes		Yes						Yes
Magaziner 1990 [42]	USA	760	1984–1986	Yes	Yes		Yes						Yes
Magaziner 2000^c [43]	USA	674	1990–1991	Yes	Yes	Yes		Yes	Yes	Yes			Yes
Miller 2009 [40]	USA	205	1992–1995		Yes				Yes
Morin 2012 [24]	Canada	12139	1986–2006								Yes
Neuman 2014 [28]	USA	60111	2005–2007	Yes	Yes				Yes				Yes
Osnes 2004 [25]	Norway	1002	1996–1997	Yes	Yes						Yes
Pereira 2010 [39]	Brazil	246	2001	Yes									Yes
Pitto 1994 [29]	Italy	143	1985–1987			Yes				Yes			Yes
Samuelsson 2009 [45]	Sweden	2134	2003	Yes	Yes						Yes		Yes
Shah 2001 [47]	USA	850	1987–1996	Yes	Yes		Yes				Yes		Yes
Ström 2008 [36]	Sweden	283	NR									Yes
Suriyawongpaisal 2003 [26]	Thailand	250	NR	Yes		Yes						Yes
Vergara 2014 [38]	Spain	638	NR		Yes		Yes
Vochteloo 2013 [37]	Netherlands	390	2008–2009	Yes									Yes
Wang 2015 [12]	China	1151	2008–2012			Yes							Yes
Wong 2002 [27]	Singapore	274	1991–1993	Yes									Yes

^aYes indicates how the study outcomes are categorised according to the ICF framework
^{b, c, d, f, g} indicates hip fracture patients from same cohort
^ePopulation-based cohort study with comparison to non-fracture group
Accomm accommodations, ADL activities of daily living, IADL instrumental activities of daily living, ICF International Classification of Functioning, NR not reported, QOL quality of life

Back to article page

ISSN: 1471-2318

Contact us

Submission enquiries: bmcgeriatrics@biomedcentral.com
General enquiries: ORSupport@springernature.com