Skip to main content

Table 4 Professionals’ experiences with intervention delivery

From: Evaluating the social fitness Programme for older people with cognitive problems and their caregivers: lessons learned from a failed trial

 

Barriers for intervention deliverya)

Facilitators for intervention deliverya)

Theme 1

Social Fitness Programme guideline factors

Categories theme 1

- Intervention length too short for structural behaviour change

- Professionals were motivated to participate in the SF study

- Goal setting focused the intervention

- Additional attention for caregiver

Theme 2

Individual health professional factors

Categories theme 2

- Lack of clarity regarding own role during intervention delivery

- Reservations in referring clients to welfare professionals

- Little experience in SF programme performance

- Illness of volunteer

- Professionals put more effort into treatment as a result of their clients participating in research

- GP supported participation in the SF programme and coordinated all care initiatives

Theme 3

Client and caregiver factors

Categories theme 3

- Lack of internal motivation to increase social participation expressed by people with cognitive problems

- Increased caregiver burden during intervention delivery

- Changing needs (i.e. as a result of physical problems)

- Client was unwilling to transfer from own PT to intervention PT

- Caregiver had limited time available

- Caregiver/client had difficulties in handling cognitive decline

- Client had difficulties in prioritising

- Expressed need for support to maintain or increase functioning in the home environment

- Clients’ motivation to contribute in research and therefore participate in the SF programme (i.e. contribute to society)

- Client was motivated to participate (i.e. to prevent necessity of client for going to day-care; happy to share her story)

Theme 4

Professional interactions

Categories theme 4

- Suboptimal sharing of information among SF professionals

- Lack of coordination, too many people involved alongside SF Programme

- Difficulties in reaching WP

- Collaboration improved during the study

- Professionals were already used to working together

- Dementia Casemanager motivated clients for OT

Theme 5

Incentives and resources

Categories theme 5

- Limited availability of organised social activities in the community which suit the participants with cognitive problems

- Lack of PT reimbursement by health insurance

- Not applicable

Theme 6

Organisational resources

Categories theme 6

- Rearrangement resulted in discontinuity of welfare professionals

- Not applicable

  1. a Italic barriers and facilitators originate from OT and PT medical records
  2. SF Social fitness, GP General Practitioner, OT Occupational Therapy, PT Physiotherapy